Got three quotes in front of you?
Choosing the cheapest one might seem like the obvious way to save money. However, the lowest price isn’t always the best deal.
Knowing how to compare quotes properly can help you spot missing costs, understand what you’re actually paying for and choose the right professional for the job.
Before you say yes to any quote, compare these 10 things.
1. Check that every quote covers the same work
Start with the scope of work.
Two quotes can look similar while covering completely different services.
For example, one builder might include:
- Removing old materials
- Supplying new materials
- Installation
- Waste removal
- Cleaning afterwards
Another may only quote for labour and installation.
Therefore, don’t compare the final prices until you’ve checked exactly what’s included.
2. Compare the materials
Cheaper isn’t always cheaper if lower-quality materials are being used.
Check whether each quote specifies:
- Material type
- Brand
- Quantity
- Quality or specification
- Who supplies the materials
For larger home improvement projects, ask for clarification if the materials aren’t clearly listed.
3. Check whether VAT is included
This is an easy detail to miss.
A quote for £3,000 + VAT is very different from a quote for £3,000 including VAT.
Make sure you know whether VAT applies before comparing the totals.
4. Look for additional charges
The headline price doesn’t always tell the full story.
Check for possible extras such as:
- Call-out charges
- Delivery fees
- Waste disposal
- Parking
- Equipment hire
- Additional labour
- Travel costs
Ask the business what could cause the final price to increase.
5. Compare the payment terms
Next, check when you’ll actually have to pay.
For larger projects, a quote may include:
- Initial deposit
- Material payment
- Stage payments
- Final balance
Be cautious about paying the entire cost upfront.
A clear payment schedule makes it easier to understand your financial commitment.
6. Compare timescales
Price isn’t the only thing that matters.
One professional might be able to start next week, while another may not be available for two months.
Check:
- Proposed start date
- Estimated completion date
- Number of working days
- How delays will be handled
A slightly higher quote may be worthwhile if the service better fits your schedule.
7. Check guarantees and warranties
A cheaper quote may offer little protection once the job is complete.
Ask whether the price includes:
- Workmanship guarantee
- Manufacturer warranty
- Parts guarantee
- Aftercare
Also, check how long each guarantee lasts and what it actually covers.
8. Compare experience and reviews
Don’t compare quotes based on price alone.
Research each business before deciding.
Look at:
- Customer reviews
- Similar completed projects
- Relevant qualifications
- Experience
- Insurance
- Professional memberships where relevant
A professional with strong experience may charge more but offer better overall value.
9. Watch for suspiciously cheap quotes
Imagine receiving three quotes:
| Business | Quote |
|---|---|
| Business A | £4,800 |
| Business B | £5,200 |
| Business C | £2,700 |
Business C might look like a bargain.
However, you should ask why it’s so much cheaper.
Perhaps the business has lower overheads. That’s perfectly possible.
But it could also mean:
- Materials are missing.
- Waste removal isn’t included.
- The specification is different.
- Additional charges will appear later.
- Lower-quality materials are being used.
Don’t automatically reject a cheap quote. Instead, investigate the difference.
10. Compare value, not just price
Finally, ask yourself:
Which quote offers the best overall value?
Consider the combination of:
✔ Price
✔ Materials
✔ Experience
✔ Reviews
✔ Guarantees
✔ Timescale
✔ Communication
✔ What’s actually included
The best quote isn’t necessarily the cheapest or the most expensive.
It’s the one that gives you the right balance of price, quality and confidence.
Quick quote comparison checklist
Before hiring anyone, check:
| What to compare | Quote 1 | Quote 2 | Quote 3 |
|---|---|---|---|
| Same scope of work | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Materials specified | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Labour included | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| VAT confirmed | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Waste removal included | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Start date provided | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Completion estimate | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Guarantee included | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Insurance checked | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
| Reviews checked | ☐ | ☐ | ☐ |
This makes it much easier to compare quotes like for like.
Questions to ask before accepting a quote
If anything isn’t clear, ask:
- Is this the final price?
- Is VAT included?
- Are all materials included?
- Which materials will you use?
- Is waste removal included?
- Could anything increase the price?
- When can you start?
- How long should the work take?
- What guarantee do you provide?
- What happens if additional work is needed?
A reputable professional should be willing to explain their quote clearly.
Quote vs estimate: what’s the difference?
They’re not necessarily the same.
A quote generally provides a price for specified work based on the information available.
An estimate is an indication of what the job is likely to cost.
Therefore, always check which one you’ve received and what conditions apply to the price.
Frequently Asked Questions
How many quotes should I get?
For significant work, comparing at least three quotes is a useful starting point.
It gives you a better idea of the typical price and makes unusual quotes easier to identify.
Should I always choose the middle quote?
No.
There’s no rule that the middle quote provides the best value.
Compare what’s included instead.
Why are my quotes so different?
Businesses may use different materials, labour rates, methods and pricing structures.
If there’s a large difference, ask each professional to explain what’s included.
Should I accept a verbal quote?
For significant work, get the details in writing.
This gives both you and the business a clear record of what was agreed.
Final thoughts
Learning how to compare quotes properly could prevent one of the most common hiring mistakes: choosing a price without understanding what’s behind it.
Compare the scope of work, materials, additional charges, guarantees, timescales and reputation of each business.
Then choose the professional offering the best overall value, not simply the smallest number at the bottom of the page.
Ready to compare local professionals?
Don’t hire based on one quote.
Use The Right Guy to discover local professionals, compare businesses, read customer reviews and request quotes for your project.
Run a local service business? Create your free business listing on The Right Guy and put your business in front of customers actively looking for your services.
Author: manager
Company test